|
true
rival of Asashoryu. While each on his day is able to defeat the
yokozuna, a combination of injuries, poor form and individual
inadequacies has meant the ozeki (as a collective) are no match for the
consistency of Asashoryu. They, unconsciously, have challenged
him as “a platoon”, whereby one or perhaps two are close to Asashoryu
for a majority of the basho but never all five. LH: Thank you Howard, for this interesting slant. Since my main point is not being disputed – that a rival such as Wajima could not have possibly taken seven yusho from Asashoryu during his run so far – it appears you’ve accepted it as a valid one. As far as Wajima giving Asashoryu something to think about, I’ll just offer that it’s dubious that the presence of an additional yusho threat would affect someone with Asashoryu’s robust mental character. If a 28-year-old Wajima would suddenly cruise up to the dohyo in his limousine and exit in a mawashi, I’m sure that Asashoryu would hurl something like, “Bring it on!” and the only person trembling would be someone named Uchidate. But now let’s get to the core of the discussion, and compare Asashoryu’s opposition to that of some of the other four yokozuna I mentioned. During his nearly nine-year heyday, Chiyonofuji faced five ozeki who didn’t make yokozuna…Kotokaze, Asashio, Hokutenyu, Wakashimazu and Konishiki. This quintet won 10 yusho during their collective careers, which is actually one less than the total amassed so far by the current trio of Kaio, Tochiazuma and Chiyotaikai. What’s more, the four primary yokozuna faced by Chinofuji: Takanosato, Futahaguro, Onokuni, and Asahifuji, themselves only posted 10 yusho collectively. |
The
presence of Chiyonofuji’s yokozuna heya-mate, Hokutoumi, was probably a
wash, as some of his five yusho during Chiyo’s heyday could have been
Chiyo’s, but he also prevented some of the other challengers from
winning some as well. Looking at all of this, the three current ozeki stack up as exceptional – certainly anything but weak. And to think that Asashoryu rose up the ranks behind them and blew right on by them all is just astounding! Moreover, he continues to dominate them whether they are hurting or healthy. Although comparing athletes from different eras is admittedly a fruitless exercise, when you consider the ease with which Asashoryu has set aside these three ozeki and brawny sekiwake like Kotomitsuki and Wakanosato, it’s unreasonable to imagine that he couldn’t have at least equaled Chiyonofuji’s success against the Wolf’s opposition, especially when you consider that Chiyonofuji encountered these nine men over nearly nine years, while Asashoryu is only three and a half years into his heyday. If he continues at his present pace for three more years, the numbers will simply overwhelm any attempt to suggest that he wins because of weak opposition, and the discussion we’re having now will never again get off the ground. But for the present, when you consider the cumulative records of Kaio, Tochiazuma, and Chiyotaikai, I can’t count them as weak. And also, there’s Hakuho, and Kotooshu before he was injured…. HG: I don’t think it’s accurate to use the career records of today’s ozeki to judge their current competitiveness. I do agree that the three veterans have had impressive careers, but for each and every one of them, their day in the sun has come and gone. All three struggle with persistent, |
chronic injuries and ailments that have whittled away at their physical abilities on the dohyo. In their primes they might have been able to challenge Asashoryu but age has overcome them. Tochiazuma and Chiyotaikai are both 30 and Kaio is 34. Chiyotaikai has the best record over this time, perhaps owing to being kyujo less than the others, with 207 wins, 119 losses and 34 absences. Kaio is 190-105-65, and Tochiazuma is 169-101-90 in the 24 basho. Collectively, they have been kyujo 16 times during Asashoryu’s period of dominance, while Asashoryu himself has only had to withdraw twice. Only five of their collective 11 yusho have come during Asashoryu’s heyday. In one of these Asashoryu was kyujo and in another he was horribly prepared and went 9-6 as a result. A third yusho came when Asashoryu was in his first basho as yokozuna and the media scrutiny was intense. Hakuho and Kotooshu are so new to the rank that it is hard to get a true indication of their abilities as yusho candidates and future threats to Asashoryu’s dominance. Both have shot up the ranks with lightning speed, and have some impressive accomplishments on the books already. Hakuho already has one yusho (when Asashoryu was injured), one playoff loss, and has been the runner-up five times during Asashoryu’s heyday (he’s only been in makuuchi for 15 basho). Kotooshu already has been in a playoff with Asashoryu and has been runner-up on two other occasions. Both of them are much younger than Next |
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||