|
Eternal Banzuke – Phase Four |
with
rikishi that had little impact in their own era, and whose names most
fans would never recognize. The number was set at 30 appearances,
from the first makuuchi appearance to the last: i.e., a five-year
run. Like life, this concept isn’t fair to all, Chiyonofuji being a prime example. He made one initial ‘cameo’ makuuchi appearance before dipping back to juryo and makushita for 13 basho. Since starting the calculation with his first makuuchi appearance meant including those 13 intervening basho – and thinking how unfair this was – I tried using some rules designed to exclude sub-makuuchi appearances before, and even after their makuuchi careers were ‘established.’ That just became too complicated, so ultimately, it was just decided that the career is what the record says it is. Since the Eternal Banzuke doesn’t use longevity, maybe when it’s complete – or even before then if someone else wants to go for it – an EB2 can be done based on the number of basho for which a rikishi held his highest rank, or something like that. But then the fairness component would creep in again because while someone might have been at his highest rank for only one basho, he might have been at his next highest rank for many, so then you’d establish a separate ranking for each makuuchi rank. That would lead to some rikishi appearing multiple times, making it hard to discern what you were really looking at. Maybe someone has an idea that’s more workable? Another fairness issue is, however, addressed in the EB, and that’s
|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Only
slight progress was made in continuing the Eternal Banzuke, mostly due
to ill health and additional duties, so we’ll just recap here what’s
been done so far. Also, I’ve got to say now that I realize that,
in the beginning, I didn’t fully appreciate how it could and should be
used. I’ll take a few whacks at getting that part straight here,
but first, just a reminder that the Banzuke is being built by studying
the careers of all rikishi, going back in time and taking them one by
one as their names show up on a banzuke. The EB idea came during development of the Elevator Rikishi when I wondered if there was any connection between a rikishi’s elevator tendencies and his ‘natural’ place on the banzuke. I used a median rank to determine this natural place, and later wondered if the median rank itself would be useful. It is, after all, illustrative of a rikishi’s entire career performance, and provides – in and of itself – some indication of the kind of career he had. But since I really didn’t grasp how it could be easily misinterpreted, I didn’t present it accurately. (In earlier issues, the term median rank was dubbed ‘highest median rank,’ the word ‘highest’ being redundant.) |
The
median rank is simply the highest rank the rikishi held at least 50% of
the time. So it’s going to show – at a glance – where the rikishi
spent the majority of his career, compared to the other rikishi.
It shouldn’t be used to make a judgment about who was better or
stronger but it does show some things, as long they are put in the
right perspective. For example, there is an ex-yokozuna who
doesn’t even make sanyaku on the EB, while an ex-ozeki shows up as
M6. This means that both Takanosato and Kirishima struggled at
the lower ranks before achieving their potential. It also
represents how Akebono soared up the ranks while Chiyonofuji was a late
bloomer. At first I thought the EB could show each rikishi’s entire career, from jonokuchi and on up, but then I realized that lower division records from long ago might be hard to come by, and also that I just wouldn’t have the time; so this one just covers the makuuchi careers, from the first makuuchi appearance to the last. Although longevity isn’t a factor in the EB – and isn’t intended to be since skill or strength isn’t implied – it was decided that a minimum number of basho would be required so the Banzuke isn’t cluttered |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|